Moore Architects replaced the undersized windows on this 1940s colonial with larger, more generously placed ones. Shed dormers added to the front elevation inject yet more light into the house.

Moore Architects replaced the undersized windows on this 1940s colonial with larger, more generously placed ones. Shed dormers added to the front elevation inject yet more light into the house.

best feature: robust symmetry

to do:

  • add kitchen/family room/breakfast room
  • open up first floor
  • keep some formality

The center-hall colonial revival is a lot like a well-made tuxedo: It outlasts trends and is perfect for formal occasions. But, as with a tux, it's unyielding for everyday situations. The living room usually sits too far away from the kitchen and dining room to serve as the comfortable gathering area today's families want. And a solid wall barricades the kitchen from the dining room. While the arrangement suits a sit-down dinner party for the boss, it's woefully unconducive to more relaxed meals and activities.

Most architects know a few tricks to loosen up the colonial within its original footprint. Sarah Susanka likes to create an opening behind the main stairs, connecting the living room and kitchen. On a recent remodel to a 1930s colonial, Guilford, Conn., architect Russell Campaigne, AIA, installed frosted pocket doors between the kitchen and dining room to lend some transparency. And Branford, Conn., architect Matt Schoenherr, AIA, author of the book Colonials, finds new purposes for formal areas. After adding on more casual spaces, he'll turn a little-used living room into a library, study, or game room.

The architects kept and painted the original brick but replaced the old siding, adding Craftsman-style exterior details.

The architects kept and painted the original brick but replaced the old siding, adding Craftsman-style exterior details.

Credit: Hoachlander Davis Photography

The old-fashioned formality of colonials, though, is often what attracts buyers to them in the first place. People want both sides of the coin: proper living and dining rooms, as well as places to kick back and relax. So a popular strategy is a rear or side addition incorporating a new kitchen, family room, and breakfast room. Schoenherr cautions architects planning side-of-the-house additions against falling into a common trap. “The colonial is a very defined house type, with its two-story form and symmetrical facade,” he says. “Additions to the sides seem to work best when they step down and back so the original front stays central. If you extend the facade to one side, the house loses that central focus.”

As venerable as the colonial is, not everyone wants to keep its easily recognizable style intact. Its intricate moldings, especially on prewar versions, can be hard to replicate. And some owners just want a different kind of house.Boston Modernists Ruhl Walker Architects remodeled one by overlaying its traditional facade with simply clad planes that, as Will Ruhl, AIA, says, “act like a mask for the house behind.” The colonial also converts fairly easily to other traditional house styles. “In some cases, the objective is to make it more of a farmhouse,” says Schoenherr. “We'll add a porch to the front and stray from the colonial details.”

project: Private residence, Falls Church, Va.
architect: 
Moore Architects, Alexandria, Va.
general contractor: Jeff Beuttel, Columbia, Md.
project size before: 1,741 square feet
project size after: 2,967 square feet
construction cost: $165 per square foot

Revisions of Home

  • split-level

    Hands-down, the split-level owns the title of architects' least favorite house to remodel. “It's a difficult type to work with because it's...

     
  • ranch

    Perhaps no other house type has inspired as much love and loathing as the ranch. This descendant of Frank Lloyd Wright's Usonian houses...

     
  • cape cod

    Ever since it rose to nationwide prominence as one of Levittown's main house types, the Cape's spare, one-and-a-half-story elevation has...

     
  • bungalow

    Judging from the high percentage of architects who live in remodeled bungalows, this house type holds enduring appeal for the...

     
  • foursquare

    Take a look at a typical foursquare floor plan, and its practical Midwestern roots become instantly apparent. No space is wasted on...

     
  • revisions of home

    Out of the millions of houses built in the United States from the early 1900s through the 1970s, the vast majority qualify as a classic...